Is It Cruel to Bring My Bonded Tabby Cats Indoors to Live in a Small Apa... (Vet Answered)

ℹ️Paulette asks about their cat, 2 bonded ferals (Tabby )
🗓️Asked on 28 April 2026
Vet Icon

This question has been answered by a vet

Dr. Karyn Kanowski
Dr. Karyn Kanowski BVSc, MRCVS

Small Animal Veterinarian

Dr. Karyn is a small animal veterinarian originally from Australia, now based in the UK. She holds degrees in Veterinary Science (2010) and Zoology. When not helping pets, she tends to her 5 cats and garden!

The Question

Is it cruel to trap my bonded feral cats I’ve been caring for and bring them inside to live in my small basement apt

Quick Info about 2 bonded ferals

Age: 4 years
Sex: Male
Neutered/Spayed: Yes
Breed: Tabby
Weight: 12 lbs
Location: USA
Dr. Karyn Kanowski
Dr. Karyn replied on 18 June 2026

📹 Vet's Video Reply (scroll down to see text answer)

Dear Paulette,

This is a tricky one, as there’s not really a ‘one size fits all’ answer, and it is very much going to depend on how ‘feral’ these cats are, how old they are, and what sort of exercise and enrichment you would be able to offer. 

Obviously, there are huge health and safety benefits to keeping cats indoors, but it isn’t always something they’re instinctively comfortable with.

Some people might say that it would be out of the question to force cats that have been living free into a confined area, but that isn’t necessarily true. Some cats that have been living rough seem almost grateful for the security and comfort of an indoor lifestyle, but others are going to find it stifling, and it could cause a significant amount of stress and anxiety for both them and you.

The first thing to do, if you haven’t already, is get them assessed by a vet and make sure they are neutered/spayed and vaccinated. If they haven’t been fixed, they are really going to struggle with the idea of staying inside, and you will probably struggle with the noise and smell!

If you can create lots of hiding places, cat trees, and shelves for them to climb and explore, this will help them feel safe and provide them with a way to exercise and stretch their legs. Using calming scents and pheromones can also help to create a calm and feline-friendly atmosphere, so it would be a good idea to get those working before you bring these kitties inside.

Being a small basement apartment, it’s important that they have access to fresh air and sunlight, so you may want to think about some sort of window catio, or even training them to walk on a harness (though this might be asking a bit too much of them).

All cats will have a period of adjustment when moving to a new environment, so if you are going to try this, you’ll want to give them several weeks, possibly months, to get used to their home before deciding whether or not this is going to work. 

Ultimately, you want what’s best for these cats, and it would be great if that is living with you in your apartment, but it’s also important that you’re prepared in case this is simply too big an adjustment. 

If you would like to talk about this in more detail, you can make an appointment for an online consultation at PangoVet.com.

I hope that everything works out for you and these cats, as it’s wonderful that you’re looking out for them. 

All the best,

- Dr Karyn

Disclaimer: The advice provided here is for informational purposes only and does not constitute a medical diagnosis. Always consult your local vet for emergencies.
📋

More Vet Answers